Influencers loved it

Der Dutchman

Sarasota, FL

5 creators · 9 posts · 1.2M views

DirectionsWebsiteSave

At the restaurant right now?

No check-ins yet. Your location is checked once to confirm you are here and is not stored.

Been here? Call it.

No visitor calls yet.

What to order

Garlic Mashed Potatoescrispy broasted chickenhomemade mashed potatoes and gravybuttery noodlesmacaroni & cheesedonut

8 more posts

Vacation EducationYouTube · Sep 17, 2026 · 257.1K views

“Vacay-J and my dad, Vacay-J “D,” are finally visiting Der Dutchman in Sarasota, Florida”

crispy broasted chickenhomemade mashed potatoes and gravybuttery noodlesmacaroni & cheese
positive
Latin ChopsticksYouTube · Sep 16, 2026 · 985 views

“#DerDutchman #AmishBuffet #SarasotaEats #AmishFlorida”

donutcreamy custardbutterscotch caramel topping
positive
Latin ChopsticksYouTube · Sep 14, 2026 · 222 views

“The skin? Super crispy! The chicken? Juicy! But... it's missing something.”

Crispy Fried Chickenfried chicken
mixed
Latin ChopsticksYouTube · Sep 13, 2026 · 23.2K views

“Der Dutchman https://dhgroup.com/restaurants/der-dutchman-sarasota-fl/ 3713 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34232”

mashed potatoes
mixed
Strictly DumplingYouTube · Aug 21, 2026 · 319.5K views

“an all you can eat Amish BBQ dinner buffet at Der Dutchman, voted the #1 best buffet in America”

all you can eat Amish BBQ dinner buffet
positive
Mike ChenYouTube · Jul 7, 2025 · 44.2K views

“The Der Dutchman Restaurant in Sarasota, Florida was officially voted USA Today’s #1 Buffet in America.”

positive
Timmy's TakeoutYouTube · May 31, 2025 · from 16:45 · 222.4K views

“the all you can eat amish buffet in sarasota florida called Der Dutchman and i had such a fun meal”

all you can eat amish buffet
positive
Timmy's TakeoutYouTube · Nov 9, 2024 · 282.4K views

“I've never been to an amish all you can eat buffet so I finally decided to go and review all the food I possibly could!”

How we know

Every post above links to its source. What was said and what was eaten come from the post's own words; the link to this restaurant is confirmed by a reviewer or made by the place resolver above its confidence threshold, as stated for each post. The place is verified against google places. Address: 3713 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34232.

Latin Chopsticks · YouTube · Sep 18, 2026 · source
A reviewer confirmed the suggested place on Sep 29, 2026. Extraction confidence 60%.
  • caption “#DerDutchman #AmishBuffet #AmishFlorida” source
  • caption “Cheesy, garlicky, and surprisingly creamy.” source
Reviewer note: Der Dutchman in Sarasota, the only Florida one, as the #AmishFlorida tag says.
Vacation Education · YouTube · Sep 17, 2026 · source
Auto-linked by the place resolver at 100% confidence. Extraction confidence 97%.
  • caption “Vacay-J and my dad, Vacay-J “D,” are finally visiting Der Dutchman in Sarasota, Florida” source
  • caption “We dug into Der Dutchman’s famous crispy broasted chicken, homemade mashed potatoes and gravy, buttery noodles, macaroni & cheese, green beans, creamed corn, stuffing, soups, salads, homemade rolls and plenty more Amish comfort-food favorites.” source
  • caption “One of the highlights of the entire visit was meeting our wonderful waitress Susie” source
Latin Chopsticks · YouTube · Sep 16, 2026 · source
Auto-linked by the place resolver at 93% confidence. Extraction confidence 75%.
  • caption “#DerDutchman #AmishBuffet #SarasotaEats #AmishFlorida” source
  • caption “Okay, so this donut is ridiculously delicious!” source
Latin Chopsticks · YouTube · Sep 14, 2026 · source
Auto-linked by the place resolver at 93% confidence. Extraction confidence 70%.
  • caption “Crispy Fried Chicken Review: Flavorful but Needs Salt!” source
  • caption “The skin? Super crispy! The chicken? Juicy! But... it's missing something.” source
  • caption “#DerDutchman #SarasotaEats #AmishBuffet” source
Latin Chopsticks · YouTube · Sep 13, 2026 · source
Auto-linked by the place resolver at 100% confidence. Extraction confidence 98%.
  • caption “Der Dutchman https://dhgroup.com/restaurants/der-dutchman-sarasota-fl/ 3713 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34232” source
  • caption “it was some of the BEST mashed potatoes I’ve ever had in my LIFE!” source
  • caption “those expectations dwindled VERY quickly.” source
Strictly Dumpling · YouTube · Aug 21, 2026 · source
A reviewer confirmed the suggested place on Oct 3, 2026. Extraction confidence 97%.
  • caption “an all you can eat Amish BBQ dinner buffet at Der Dutchman, voted the #1 best buffet in America” source
Reviewer note: Only place by this name the provider found (Der Dutchman, name 1); the post's clues agree on the state (Sarasota, FL) but name no town. Bulk review 2026-10-03.
Mike Chen · YouTube · Jul 7, 2025 · source
Auto-linked by the place resolver at 97% confidence. Extraction confidence 97%.
  • caption “The Der Dutchman Restaurant in Sarasota, Florida was officially voted USA Today’s #1 Buffet in America.” source
  • caption “This Amish Buffet was Voted the #1 BEST Buffet in America!” source
Timmy's Takeout · YouTube · May 31, 2025 · source
Auto-linked by the place resolver at 100% confidence. Extraction confidence 95%.
  • caption “the all you can eat amish buffet in sarasota florida called Der Dutchman and i had such a fun meal” source
  • caption “Dinner at Der Dutchman Buffet” source
Timmy's Takeout · YouTube · Nov 9, 2024 · source
Auto-linked by the place resolver at 100% confidence. Extraction confidence 97%.
  • caption “I went to the Der Dutchman buffet and bakery in Sarasota Florida!” source
  • caption “I've never been to an amish all you can eat buffet so I finally decided to go and review all the food I possibly could!” source

Own this restaurant? Claim itKnow the owner? Invite them