Creators loved it

Lucky Charlie

Brooklyn, NY

5 creators · 6 posts · 1M views

DirectionsWebsiteSave

At the restaurant right now?

No check-ins yet. Your location is checked once to confirm you are here and is not stored.

Been here? Call it.

No visitor calls yet.

EaterYouTube · Feb 21, 2026 · 781K views

“Lucky Charlie in Brooklyn is using an oven from 1890 to make their wood-fired pies.”

positive

What to order

thin crust pizza with sauce on top of cheeseNew York pizzawood-fired piesCoal-fired pizzaclassic coal-fired pizzas40-month Parmesan Reggiano

5 more posts

Beli AppYouTube · Jul 21, 2026 · 12.3K views

“📍Lucky Charlie”

positive
Scott's Pizza ToursYouTube · May 27, 2026 · 21.3K views

“you’ll still see this “inverted” style at legendary spots like Totonno’s, Juliana’s, Grimaldi’s, John’s of Bleecker, Arturo’s, and Lucky Charlie”

thin crust pizza with sauce on top of cheese
positive
imma_eat_thisYouTube · Jan 25, 2026 · 102.6K views

“A REVIEW OF LUCKY CHARLIE 📍 254 Irving Ave Brooklyn, NY #foodie #food #pizza #foodreview”

UA EatsYouTube · Nov 7, 2025 · 70.1K views

“a coal-fired pizza restaurant has newly opened in NYC”

Coal-fired pizza
Scott's Pizza ToursYouTube · Oct 10, 2025 · 25.6K views

“It's delicious, it's classic, and it's a perfect example of a newly-revived oven from the late 1800s.”

classic coal-fired pizzas40-month Parmesan Reggianomozzarella directly on the dough
positive
How we know

Every post above links to its source. What was said and what was eaten come from the post's own words; the link to this restaurant is confirmed by a reviewer or made by the place resolver above its confidence threshold, as stated for each post. The place is verified against google places. Address: 254 Irving Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237.

Beli App · YouTube · Jul 21, 2026 · source
A reviewer confirmed the suggested place on Oct 3, 2026. Extraction confidence 90%.
  • caption “📍Lucky Charlie” source
Reviewer note: Same business (Lucky Charlie, name 1) in the town the post names (Brooklyn, NY, place 1). Bulk review 2026-10-03.
Scott's Pizza Tours · YouTube · May 27, 2026 · source
A reviewer confirmed the suggested place on Oct 3, 2026. Extraction confidence 80%.
  • caption “you’ll still see this “inverted” style at legendary spots like Totonno’s, Juliana’s, Grimaldi’s, John’s of Bleecker, Arturo’s, and Lucky Charlie” source
Reviewer note: Only place by this name the provider found (Lucky Charlie, name 1); the post's clues agree on the state (Brooklyn, NY) but name no town. Bulk review 2026-10-03.
Eater · YouTube · Feb 21, 2026 · source
Auto-linked by the place resolver at 100% confidence. Extraction confidence 97%.
  • caption “Lucky Charlie in Brooklyn is using an oven from 1890 to make their wood-fired pies.” source
  • caption “hear more about their ethos from chef-owner Nino Coniglio.” source
imma_eat_this · YouTube · Jan 25, 2026 · source
Auto-linked by the place resolver at 97% confidence. Extraction confidence 95%.
  • caption “A REVIEW OF LUCKY CHARLIE 📍 254 Irving Ave Brooklyn, NY #foodie #food #pizza #foodreview” source
UA Eats · YouTube · Nov 7, 2025 · source
Auto-linked by the place resolver at 100% confidence. Extraction confidence 98%.
  • caption “a coal-fired pizza restaurant has newly opened in NYC” source
  • caption “Hence the name of the restaurant, Lucky Charlie!” source
  • caption “Lucky Charlie 254 Irving Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237” source
Scott's Pizza Tours · YouTube · Oct 10, 2025 · source
Auto-linked by the place resolver at 93% confidence. Extraction confidence 97%.
  • caption “His new spot, Lucky Charlie in Bushwick, Brooklyn, is home to a truly unique piece of pizza history” source
  • caption “It's delicious, it's classic, and it's a perfect example of a newly-revived oven from the late 1800s.” source

Own this restaurant? Claim itKnow the owner? Invite them